A major Australian bank’s chief executive has said home loans barely cover the cost of capital for the group. That is a striking admission from a lender that still writes a large share of its mortgages through brokers. The detail behind the comment was not available to us, so treat the figures with care. The direction of the message, though, matters for anyone hoping competition will keep cutting their rate.
The short version: thin mortgage margins put a floor under pricing, and broker-channel rivalry cannot push below it for long.
Why mortgage margins are so tight
A home loan looks safe, and that is exactly the problem. Because the risk of loss is low, regulators let banks hold relatively little capital against each loan. But the competition for those loans is fierce, so the interest rate gets squeezed toward the lender’s own funding cost.
Put simply, the spread between what a bank pays to fund a loan and what it charges you is narrow. Out of that spread it must cover operating costs, expected losses, broker commissions and a return on the capital it has to hold. When the spread shrinks, the return on that capital shrinks with it.
In plain English
- Funding cost: what the bank pays to raise the money it lends.
- Capital: the shareholder-owned buffer the bank must hold against possible losses.
- Margin: what is left after funding and running costs, before the return on capital.
How capital settings shape the price you see
Regulatory capital rules decide how much of a bank’s own money must sit behind each loan. Larger banks that use their own risk models generally hold less capital per mortgage than smaller lenders using the standardised approach. That gives the big banks a pricing advantage, but it does not make mortgages a rich business.
The catch is that a bank only has so much capital to deploy. If a mortgage earns a return close to its cost of capital, management will ask why it should grow that book rather than lend elsewhere. Business lending, deposits and wealth products can look more attractive per dollar of capital. That is the logic behind a lender saying mortgages are not at the centre of its strategy.
Why broker competition has a ceiling
Brokers now write a majority share of new home loans in Australia, which means they do much of the price shopping on a borrower’s behalf. In theory that should drive rates down. In practice, three things limit it.
- Commissions are part of the cost. Upfront and trail payments sit inside the margin. A lender cannot cut its rate sharply without either squeezing a thin spread further or reducing what it pays the channel.
- Cashbacks and discounts are targeted. Lenders tend to aim their sharpest offers at new customers or refinancers, and fund them by leaving existing borrowers on higher rates.
- Everyone faces similar funding costs. When rivals raise money at roughly the same price, there is only so much room to undercut each other without losing money on the loan.
So a busy broker channel can still produce a lot of switching and plenty of marketing, yet leave the headline rate difference between lenders modest.
Volume recovery does not mean fatter margins
The source headline pointed to a recovery in lending volumes. More loans written is not the same as more profit per loan. A lender chasing volume in a market with thin spreads may be growing its balance sheet while earning little extra for the capital it ties up.
This is why a bank can report healthy loan growth and still describe mortgages as marginal. Volume and profitability are different measures, and the gap between them is where borrower pricing gets decided.
What could change the picture
A few things could shift the economics, and none are certain.
- Capital rules. Any change to how much capital banks hold against mortgages would flow straight into pricing.
- Funding costs. If wholesale or deposit funding gets cheaper relative to the cash rate, margins can widen even without a policy change.
- Arrears. Higher losses would eat further into a thin spread. For context on how stress shows up before arrears do, see our look at mortgage stress in Sydney.
- Channel rules. Changes to broker remuneration or lender-broker arrangements would alter the cost of acquiring a loan.
The base case is that margins stay thin. The upside for borrowers is modest. The downside is that lenders pull back from the segment rather than compete harder, which tends to show up as tighter policy before it shows up as higher rates.
What this means if you hold a mortgage
Do not assume competition will do the work for you. The sharpest rates usually go to people who ask for them.
- Compare your current rate against what lenders advertise to new borrowers. A gap of a few tenths of a percentage point can add up to thousands over a year on a large loan.
- Ask your lender for a rate review before you ask a broker to move you. Retention discounts exist, but they are rarely offered unprompted.
- Count the switching costs. Discharge fees, a new valuation and lost cashback conditions can eat the saving.
- Check how a broker is paid, and ask for the comparison across several lenders. Our home loans, lenders and refinancing guide sets out the questions worth asking.
For the weekly signal on rates and credit, subscribe to the newsletter.
General info, not financial advice.
