Refinance share of mortgage market rises as the pool shrinks

Refinances now account for nearly a third of broker-written mortgage deals. Read quickly, that sounds like borrowers are switching lenders in record numbers. The trade press reporting on the figure points the other way: the share is up, but not because more people are moving their loans.

That gap between share and volume is the whole story. It is also easy to get wrong.

A bigger slice does not mean a bigger market

A share is a fraction. Refinances divided by all broker deals. If the bottom of that fraction shrinks, the result climbs even when the top stays flat.

Here is a simple illustration, using made-up round numbers. Say 100 loans are written in a month and 25 are refinances. The refinance share is 25 per cent. Now purchase lending cools and total loans fall to 80, while refinances hold at 25. The share jumps to about 31 per cent. Nobody switched lenders any faster. The pool just got smaller.

That is the pattern the headline describes. Refinances are taking a bigger slice of a shrinking mortgage market, and the slice is growing because the pie is getting smaller.

What a falling denominator usually signals

When new purchase lending slows, the refinance share rises almost by default. Several things can drive the slowdown:

  • Higher borrowing costs trimming what buyers can afford.
  • Tighter credit settings reducing approvals.
  • Buyers waiting for clearer signals on rates and prices.
  • Fewer sellers listing, which limits the number of purchase loans available to write.

The source summary does not break down which of these dominates, and we should not guess at the split. What matters for readers is the direction: a rising refinance share can be a symptom of weak purchase activity rather than a sign of healthy competition.

What it says about lender competition

In a market where borrowers are actively shopping around, refinance volumes should rise in absolute terms. Lenders would be fighting over existing customers with sharper pricing and cashback offers, and brokers would be writing more switches.

If volumes are flat or soft instead, the competition story is weaker than the share figure implies. Lenders may be advertising discounts, but few borrowers are acting on them. That points to friction, not appetite.

The catch: stress tests can lock borrowers in

Moving a loan is not just a pricing decision. A new lender reassesses the borrower from scratch, and that includes a serviceability test that adds a buffer on top of the actual rate. A borrower who qualified comfortably a few years ago can fail that test today, even with a clean repayment record and a lower balance.

This is the so-called mortgage prisoner problem. A borrower may be paying more than the best available rate but cannot move because the new lender’s assessment says they could not afford the loan. We covered the mechanics in more detail in mortgage prisoners and why bank stress tests block cheaper loans.

That matters here because it suggests part of the quiet in refinance volumes may reflect borrowers who want to switch but cannot clear the test, not borrowers who are happy where they are. The two groups look identical in the headline number and very different in real life.

Second-order effects

Lender capacity also plays a part. When regulators or internal risk settings limit how much new lending an institution can write, it tends to prioritise certain loans and ration others. We looked at one example in the capital overlay Macquarie faced and what it means for lending. Constraints like that can narrow the choice a refinancing borrower actually has, whatever the advertised rates say.

In plain English

A rising refinance share can mean fewer new loans, not more borrowers switching. Check the volume before you trust the percentage.

Putting that callout the way the brand requires:

Quick take

  • Share = refinances divided by total broker deals.
  • A smaller total pushes the share up on its own.
  • Locked-in borrowers and thin purchase demand can look the same in the data.

Scenarios from here

Three broad paths are plausible, each with different assumptions.

  1. Base case: purchase lending stays subdued, refinance volume stays roughly flat, and the share holds near current levels. Competition stays more talk than action.
  2. Upside case: borrowing costs ease or lenders relax serviceability buffers, more borrowers clear the test, and refinance volume rises alongside a recovery in purchase lending.
  3. Downside case: purchase lending weakens further while stress tests keep many borrowers locked in, pushing the share higher again for the wrong reasons.

The point is that the same headline percentage can come from very different market conditions. The number alone cannot tell them apart.

What to check before acting on the headline

If you are thinking about your own loan, the share figure is not much use. Better questions are specific to you:

  • What is your current rate compared with what comparable lenders advertise for your loan size and loan-to-value ratio?
  • Would a new lender’s serviceability assessment realistically accept your income and debts today?
  • What are the discharge, application and any break costs, and how long would it take for a lower rate to repay them?

Our guide to home loans, lenders and refinancing walks through how to compare these in practice.

If this helped, subscribe to the Australian Property Review newsletter for the weekly signal on rates, credit and policy.

General info, not financial advice.

Share this article

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here