New South Wales has shelved its underquoting laws for as long as twelve months, one day before they were due to start. The rules would have carried penalties of up to $110,000 or triple the agent’s commission, whichever was higher. Buyers walking into auctions in a softer market will now do it without that backstop.
The timing is the story. The reforms passed in June. They were due to take effect on Tuesday. The premier stepped in on Monday after agents in his own south Sydney seat of Kogarah raised complaints. Sydney prices have dropped 10.1% from their 2026 high, according to Cotality.
What the shelved rules would have done
The package was modelled on Victorian rules. Its core test was simple. An agent could not advertise a property below a figure the seller had already knocked back in writing.
That matters because underquoting works through the gap between the advertised guide and the price a seller will actually accept. A low guide pulls more buyers to the campaign. Some of them have already spent weekends and building-inspection money before they learn the real number. The rule tried to anchor the guide to something verifiable.
The penalty was also designed to bite. Tying the fine to a multiple of commission, with a dollar floor, meant a big-commission sale could not treat the fine as a cost of doing business.
The premier’s argument: written for a rising market
The premier’s stated reason is that the legislation implicitly assumed prices would keep climbing. The fair trading minister, who was championing the reforms as recently as 1 November, now says they were designed for a different market.
There is a logic to that. When prices are rising fast, sellers’ expectations lag the market, and guides can look low simply because values moved between appraisal and auction. Agents argue that a hard rule can punish honest misjudgement.
But the logic cuts the other way too. In a falling market, sellers often hold onto an earlier, higher number. That can leave reserves above the advertised guide for the opposite reason: the seller is anchored to last year’s price. The result for a buyer looks the same. The guide is a poor signal of where the sale could land.
Why a falling market raises the stakes
Buyers in a down market have more room to negotiate and more reason to be careful. Both depend on reliable information.
If price guides are less trustworthy, three things follow:
- Buyers spend time and fees on properties that were never realistically in their range.
- Genuine bargains get harder to spot, because the guide no longer separates the sellers who are flexible from the ones who are not.
- Campaigns that fail to meet reserve drag on, which can reinforce a sense of weak conditions without telling buyers anything useful.
That is the catch with pausing enforcement now. The conditions that make the rule feel less urgent to agents are the same conditions that make guide accuracy more valuable to buyers.
Victoria’s approach and what it shows
The NSW rules borrowed from Victoria, where the approach centres on how reserves and guides relate to each other. The sensible comparison is not whether Victoria has solved underquoting. It is that a state with a working framework can give buyers a firmer reference point, while NSW now has none of the new tools and only its existing rules.
For buyers, that means leaning harder on independent checks. Recent comparable sales, the days a similar property sat on the market, and the gap between past guides and past results are all more useful than the advertised number alone.
Politics, not policy design, drove the pause
The backdown is one of several the premier has announced in recent weeks, with a state election due in March. The government is squeezed on living costs and small business strain, with One Nation and the Coalition both pressing it. Internal Labor polling suggests One Nation could win more than 20 lower house seats, and an October poll had it on 26% of the primary vote, between Labor at 30% and the Coalition at 23%.
The fair trading minister faces a preselection contest in Macquarie Fields, and the premier would not commit to backing him. He has previously been overruled on rental and prison policy. None of that proves the pause was only about politics. But it does suggest the decision was made on a political timetable rather than after a fresh review of how the rules would behave in the current market.
The twelve-month window is also open-ended in effect. A pause that runs past an election can quietly become a repeal.
What buyers can check for themselves
If you are bidding in Sydney this season, treat the advertised guide as one input, not the answer:
- Compare the guide with recent sales of similar homes nearby, not with the agent’s recent campaigns.
- Ask the agent directly whether the seller has rejected any offer or valuation, and keep a note of the answer.
- Set your own ceiling before auction day, based on your borrowing buffer and not on the guide.
- If a campaign repeatedly passes in at prices well above its guide, factor that pattern into the next property you chase.
The broader point is simple. A rule built for a rising market was shelved in a falling one, and the gap between guide and outcome is likely to be widest when conditions are changing fastest. For readers following the wider policy picture, our guide to budget, policy and government housing schemes covers how these settings interact.
Key numbers
- Up to $110,000 or triple the agent’s commission: the penalty in the shelved rules
- Up to 12 months: the length of the pause
- 10.1%: Sydney’s fall from its 2026 high, per Cotality
- 26% vs 30% vs 23%: One Nation, Labor and the Coalition in an October poll
Subscribe to the weekly signal: Australian Property Review newsletter.
General info, not financial advice.
