Victorian rental supply is shrinking as investor loans collapse

Victoria wrote just 6819 investor loans in the September quarter. A year earlier it was 11,150. That is a fall of 4331 loans, and the weakest result since 2020, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

The number matters because it lands on top of a rental market that is already losing stock. Victorian rental supply shrank from 681,141 homes in June 2023 to 664,663 in June 2024, a loss of roughly 16,400. Renters feel that as fewer listings, more competition and rents that keep rising.

The argument now being made by industry groups is that governments helped build this squeeze. That deserves testing rather than repeating.

Lending is weaker than in the last tightening cycle

The most striking comparison is with the previous run of rate rises. Investor loans bottomed at 6890 back then. This quarter’s 6819 is lower again.

Here is the catch. Borrowing costs rose 3.75 percentage points in that earlier cycle. This year they have risen 1.25. A smaller rate shock has produced a deeper pullback, which suggests rates are not the whole story.

Something else is weighing on landlords. Industry voices point to three things stacking up.

Three policy pressures landing together

  • Land tax. A May 2023 state increase lifted the bill on a median property from $1597.50 to $3474. That is more than double, paid every year regardless of whether the home is tenanted.
  • Rental standards. Reforms to minimum standards add compliance and upgrade costs. Industry groups call them expensive.
  • Federal tax settings. A May decision to alter negative gearing and capital gains concessions changed the after-tax maths for investors.

No single change on that list is large enough to explain the drop on its own. Together they cut yield, raise holding costs and add uncertainty about what comes next. Investors price uncertainty. Many simply sell or stay out.

Key numbers

  • Investor loans: 6819 this quarter, down from 11,150
  • Rental stock: 681,141 to 664,663 homes in a year
  • Land tax on a median property: $1597.50 to $3474

First-home buyers did not fill the gap

A common defence of tougher investor settings is that owner-occupiers pick up the slack. The lending figures do not show that. First-home buyer loans also fell, from 9983 to 8337.

So the shift is not a clean handover from investors to first-home buyers. Fewer investors bought, and fewer first-timers did too. Both groups are being held back by the same things: prices, borrowing capacity and confidence. That undercuts the idea that investor exits free up homes that new owners readily absorb.

Our earlier look at first-home investor loans at a record low shows the same weakness at the entry end of the investor market.

Sell-offs add to the loss of supply

One large agency head says investor sell-offs have run at double historical levels for three years. If that holds, the rental pool is shrinking from both ends. Fewer new investors come in, and existing ones leave faster.

Not every sold rental disappears from the market. Some go to owner-occupiers, which removes a rental but houses a buyer. Others go to new investors and stay tenanted. The net effect on rent depends on who buys. The stock figures suggest the owner-occupier route is common enough to push total rental supply down.

Regulation of landlords is also moving further. Our piece on Victorian landlord licensing and a possible three-strike ban covers a proposal that could push some small landlords out.

What the supply side needs

The real estate institute’s chief executive wants governments to add supply and remove the disincentives facing landlords. That is a reasonable direction, though it hides a trade-off. Easing land tax or regulation helps landlords but costs revenue or protections that tenants value.

A building industry economist takes a different view. He argues public housing should be accelerated, and warns private construction will fall in 2027. He puts the national need at about 260,000 homes a year. Private builders respond to investor demand, so weak investor lending today feeds into thinner pipelines later.

That is the second-order effect worth watching. A lending drop this quarter can become fewer completions in two or three years, which keeps vacancy tight just when relief is supposed to arrive.

If you want the basics of how vacancy and rent interact, our rents, vacancy and tenants guide is the place to start.

Scenarios, not certainties

Base case. Investor lending stays low, rental stock keeps edging down and rents keep rising faster than wages. Policy shifts slowly.

Upside. State and federal governments soften the holding-cost burden or lift public and build-to-rent supply. Investor confidence returns gradually and listings recover.

Downside. More sell-offs plus a weaker construction pipeline in 2027 push vacancy lower again. Pressure on tenants increases, and calls for rent controls grow louder, which could deter investors further.

We should be careful about causation. The data shows investor lending and rental stock falling together. It does not prove how much each policy contributed. What it does show is that the explanation cannot be rates alone.

A practical next step

If you are a Victorian investor, run your numbers with the current land tax bill and expected compliance costs, then check what your yield looks like if you hold for five years rather than one. If you rent, expect competition to stay stiff and keep your paperwork ready.

For weekly analysis like this, subscribe to the newsletter.

General info, not financial advice.

Share this article

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here