Negative equity first-home buyers are the group to watch as Australian property values keep sliding. Moody’s Ratings has concluded that recent purchasers with small deposits are the most likely to end up owing more than their home is worth, while the wider market stays largely protected. The agency calls the trend credit negative for residential mortgage-backed securities and covered bonds.
The headline numbers are small. The mechanics behind them are not.
Why thin deposits are the weak point
The most exposed borrowers put down less than 20%. That includes buyers who used the government’s 5% deposit schemes, whose loans often sit at loan-to-value ratios (LVRs) between 80% and 95%. LVR is simply the loan as a share of the property’s value. At 95%, a fall of just 5% in value wipes out the entire deposit.
Moody’s says a market correction of 10% to 20% would substantially erode the equity of recent buyers. Prices have already fallen 8.1% from the start of April to 31 October, after rate rises and trimmed investor tax concessions. So many of these borrowers have already given back a large share of their cushion.
Key numbers
- Share of borrowers in rated pools with negative equity at 31 May: 0.39%
- Highest by state: Northern Territory 0.74%, Queensland 0.64%
- Modelled after a further 10% price fall: about 1.5%
- Modelled after a further 15% price fall: about 4.6%
- National price gain from early 2020 to June 2026: 63%
From 0.39% to 4.6%: how fast the tail grows
The starting point is low. Only 0.39% of borrowers in rated pools were underwater at 31 May. The modelling suggests that figure rises to roughly 1.5% after another 10% drop and about 4.6% after 15%. That is not a linear path. Each extra slice of price decline pulls in a bigger group of high-LVR loans, because so many were written close to the same threshold.
The 63% national gain between early 2020 and June 2026 explains why the overall picture stays contained. Anyone who bought before the run-up, or who has paid down a loan for several years, holds a large buffer. The problem is concentrated among those who bought late and borrowed heavily.
How negative equity, stress tests and valuations combine
Negative equity alone does not force anyone to sell. A borrower who keeps paying can sit through a downturn. The risk comes from three things stacking up.
First, serviceability. Lenders test loans at a rate well above the actual one, which is conservative and is part of why Moody’s sees the system as resilient. But that same buffer limits options for a borrower who wants to restructure or move. A household whose income has not grown, or has been hit by higher costs, may not pass the test on a new loan even if the existing repayments are manageable.
Second, valuations. Lenders rely on automated valuation models and desktop assessments that update with local sales. When prices fall, those figures can move against a borrower quickly. A refinance application that would have passed a year ago can come back with a lower value and an LVR above the lender’s limit.
Third, income exposure. Equifax findings from earlier this month show arrears are more common among 5% scheme borrowers who work in rate-sensitive or discretionary sectors. Those are the households most likely to lose hours or income when conditions tighten.
Put those together and a borrower can be technically current on payments yet unable to refinance, sell without a loss or access a cheaper rate. That is the trap.
What it implies for arrears and forced sales
Here is the catch. Negative equity is a risk multiplier, not a trigger. Arrears rise when a shock hits the household, such as a job loss, a relationship breakdown or a sharp rise in repayments. Negative equity changes what happens next. A borrower with positive equity can sell, repay the loan and walk away. A borrower with negative equity often cannot, so the stress is more likely to end in default or a distressed sale.
That is why the forced-sale supply question matters. If arrears among thin-deposit buyers lift, some of those properties will reach the market below recent comparable sales. That in turn can feed back into the valuations that other borrowers face. It is a second-order effect, and it is most likely to show up in the segments with the highest concentration of recent high-LVR lending.
Moody’s also points to highly leveraged owner-occupiers and some investors, including those with interest-only or recent high-LVR loans. For investors, the pressure is different. Lower rents relative to repayments and reduced tax concessions can squeeze cashflow while values fall.
Sydney and Melbourne carry the most risk
Moody’s flags Sydney and Melbourne as the riskiest markets. The reasons are weak recent price performance, the highest household debt in the country and sharper affordability strain. Higher entry prices also mean a larger dollar loan on a thin deposit, so the same percentage fall removes more actual cash from the buyer’s position.
The current state-level data tells a different story. The Northern Territory and Queensland have the highest shares of negative equity at 0.74% and 0.64%. That reflects where recent purchases and price softness have overlapped so far. The forward risk, though, sits where debt and prices are largest.
Where the commentary has split
Coverage of this research has divided along predictable lines. One reading stresses the headline reassurance: most borrowers keep positive equity, lenders stress-test conservatively and the 63% gain is a large buffer. The other reading focuses on the lock-in effect, where negative equity and tight serviceability tests keep borrowers with their current lender and complicate bank arrears modelling.
Both are right. The system is resilient, and a specific group is boxed in. The useful question is how large that group becomes if prices fall another 10% to 15%.
A practical way to use this
If you hold a high-LVR loan, the next step is to find out where you stand. Check a recent estimate of your property’s value against your loan balance, then work out how much of a price fall you could absorb before the loan exceeds the home’s value. Our mortgage stress and arrears guide walks through the warning signs, and the repayment calculator lets you test your own loan against a rate rise.
For wider context on who is entering the market, see our look at whether the first-home buyer rebound is a real shift or a rent-driven blip.
If you want the weekly signal, subscribe to the newsletter.
General info, not financial advice.
