Everyone wants to call the bottom of a property downturn. Almost nobody gets it right in real time. The more useful question for investors is a narrower one: which indicators turn before prices do, and how do you read them without wishful thinking?
That question matters now because the backdrop is still soft. One long-serving industry commentator argues that Australia’s economy and property markets are still sliding. Home values are dropping, commercial yields and interest rates are climbing, construction activity is shrinking, joblessness is rising and real per capita GDP is falling. Households are also cutting spending. The same commentator argues that disciplined investors can profit by recognising when the slide ends, and that is the idea worth testing with a proper checklist.
The short version: prices and unemployment are lagging indicators. By the time they confirm a recovery, much of the opportunity has gone. The better signals sit earlier in the chain.
Why prices are the wrong thing to watch first
Price indices are rear-view mirrors. They average sales that were agreed weeks or months earlier, so they keep falling after buyer behaviour has already started to change. Unemployment works the same way. It tends to peak after the economy has started to turn.
That is why watching headline values alone can keep you on the sidelines through the early part of a recovery. It can also trick you into buying a false dawn, because a single good month of prices rarely means much.
Six indicators, and what a floor would look like
Here is a practical scorecard. For each one, the question is whether it has stopped getting worse, not whether it looks good.
- Days on market. Properties that sit for fewer days than the month before suggest buyers are returning. A long, steady lengthening says the opposite.
- Unsold listings. A pile of stock that stops growing, then shrinks, is one of the earliest signs that supply and demand are rebalancing.
- Auction clearance rates. Look at the direction over several weeks, not one Saturday. Preliminary rates can be revised, so treat single readings with care.
- Sales volumes. Turnover usually dries up before prices fall and picks up before they recover. A rise in activity at flat prices is the pattern to look for.
- Media tone. It sounds soft, but a shift from fear stories to “is it time to buy?” stories has historically marked a change in sentiment. Use it as a cross-check only.
- Credit conditions. Do lenders look more willing to write loans? Falling rates alone may not mark the bottom, because rate cuts that arrive during a downturn often reflect weakness rather than cure it.
The point is not that all six must flash green. It is that you want several moving in the same direction for several weeks.
The wider economy gauges
Property does not turn in isolation. A second set of economic readings helps you judge whether a local improvement can last.
- Job advertisement volumes, which lead the jobs market.
- ABS retail spending, a direct read on household caution.
- Household and business confidence surveys.
- Central bank statements, for the direction of policy.
- Overseas ordering and inventory data, which can signal when business investment is about to restart.
Global events and energy costs can also override local signs. A domestic recovery can be delayed by factors that never show up in a suburb’s sales figures.
What the history says, and what it doesn’t
The commentator points to three earlier episodes. In the 1990-91 recession, mortgage rates sat near 15 per cent, credit froze and unemployment reached double digits. The 2008-2009 financial crisis was another test, and the Covid shutdown was cushioned by massive government stimulus.
The lesson is that downturns end, but the cause matters. The Covid recovery leaned heavily on stimulus that may not be repeated. A repeat of that outcome should not be assumed.
The catch
The obvious risk is trying to be early. Buying into pessimism only works if you can hold the asset through further falls. That means a cashflow buffer, a serviceability margin that survives higher rates and a job that is not exposed to the same slowdown. The commentator’s own view is that values may have further to fall, so being early and being wrong can look identical for a while.
There is also the opposite error. Waiting for certainty usually means paying more once confidence returns, because the recovery is often visible in the data well before it is visible in the news.
Where this leaves a cautious investor
The sensible approach is to keep a short, written scorecard and update it monthly. Mark each indicator as worsening, flat or improving, with the date and source. Hold off on a view until at least three of the leading indicators have stopped worsening and stayed that way, and treat any single strong month as noise.
A useful starting point is our guide to house prices, downturns and auctions, which explains how to read clearance rates properly. For the data side of the argument, see property market bottom: the data that confirms it’s real.
Quick take
- Prices and unemployment lag. Days on market, unsold listings, clearance rates and sales volumes tend to lead.
- Falling interest rates alone do not prove a floor.
- Look for several indicators improving together over several weeks.
Next step: build your own one-page scorecard this week, list the six indicators above and record where each sits today. Want a regular read on the data? Subscribe to the newsletter.
General info, not financial advice.
