A fresh report has concluded that underquoting laws are not doing what they were meant to do. The details of its findings sit behind a paywall, so this piece does not rely on its numbers. The more useful question is structural: why does a low price guide still pay, and what would make it stop paying?
Why a low guide still pays
Underquoting works because it solves a problem for the seller’s agent. A low guide pulls more people through the door. More people means more competition, and competition is what lifts a final price. The agent wants a crowded open home. The seller wants a high result. A modest guide serves both.
The buyer pays the cost. They spend weekends and money on building reports, legal checks and finance pre-approvals for homes that were never priced for them. That cost is real, but it is spread thinly across many buyers, so it rarely triggers a complaint.
The penalty is smaller than the payoff
Most enforcement regimes rely on fines and warnings after the fact. For that to deter, the expected penalty has to exceed the gain from a stronger result. Three things weaken it:
- Proving intent is hard. An agent can point to the seller’s expectations or the market’s movement between listing and sale.
- Complaints come from buyers who lost, and they have little to gain from pursuing one.
- Regulators have limited staff and tend to chase the clearest cases, not the grey zone where most guides sit.
If the odds of being caught are low and the fine is modest, the rational move for a busy agent is to keep quoting low and accept the occasional cost.
Where the rules leave gaps
Many regimes ask agents to base the guide on comparable sales and the seller’s reserve. That sounds tight, but “comparable” involves judgement, and the reserve is often set or revised late. A guide can be technically defensible and still mislead.
Our earlier coverage of Victoria’s underquoting laws showed how price guides now carry legal weight there. The weak point is not the existence of the rule. It is how easily the rule can be satisfied on paper.
The catch
- A guide can be “reasonable” and still sit well below where a sale lands
- Buyers bear the cost, but sellers and agents capture the benefit
- Penalties after the fact do little for the buyer who already wasted a month
Design changes that could shift behaviour
If the aim is to change incentives, the rules have to touch the moment the guide is published, not just the moment it is challenged. A few options are worth testing:
- Tighter, earlier evidence. Require agents to lodge the comparable sales and reserve basis with the listing, so the reasoning is on record before the campaign starts.
- Narrow guides. Cap the permitted gap between the guide and the reserve, so there is less room to quote low and defend it later.
- Real-time disclosure. Price disclosure that updates when the reserve changes cuts the lag that lets guides drift out of date.
- Consequences for the listing, not just the person. If a campaign must be relaunched after a breach, the commercial cost lands on the party that benefits.
Some of these ideas are already being tried. The NSW price disclosure rules are an early test of whether showing a number changes behaviour, and we looked at whether it will in NSW price disclosure laws: will showing a price change the result?.
Disclosure has its own trade-offs
More transparency is not free. If agents must publish a firm figure, some will quote higher and risk scaring off buyers, or shift sales to private treaty where the rules differ. We covered a version of that tension in Victoria’s auction reserve price rules. Rules that squeeze one channel can push activity into another.
That is why design matters more than volume of regulation. A rule that is easy to comply with on paper but hard to enforce in practice adds cost without changing the incentive.
What to watch as a buyer
Until the structure changes, treat the guide as a starting point, not a promise. Compare recent sales yourself, ask the agent for the basis of the range, and set your own ceiling before you attend. If you want a broader view of how housing policy settings are shifting, our guide to budget, policy and government housing schemes is a useful reference.
The next step: before your next inspection, write down the highest price you would pay, then check whether the guide gives you a real reason to believe it is reachable. Subscribe to the newsletter for weekly analysis of rules that affect what you pay.
General info, not financial advice.
