Picture a borrower paying more each month than a rival lender is offering to charge. They apply to switch. The bank says no. Not because the new repayment is unaffordable, but because it assessed them against a rate far above anything on offer. That is the trap behind the phrase mortgage prisoners, and it has grown as rates have climbed.
Key numbers
- 3 per cent: the compulsory serviceability buffer, lifted from 2.5 per cent in October 2021
- 2.59 per cent: the average rate on a loan taken out five years ago, tested then at 5.59 per cent
- 6.73 per cent: the average new owner-occupier variable rate after the latest hike
- 9.73 per cent: the rate that loan is tested at with the full buffer (7.73 per cent with a 1-point margin)
How a lower repayment still fails the test
Lenders do not assess a refinance on the repayment you would actually make. They add a margin to the new rate and ask whether you could carry the loan at that higher number. The idea is sensible: protect borrowers from a future rate rise.
The catch is what happens when your existing loan was written cheaply. Someone who borrowed at 2.59 per cent was tested at 5.59 per cent. Rates have since risen 4.75 points, counting from October 2021. A replacement loan at today’s rates, with the full buffer, is assessed at close to double that original test. Their real repayment may fall by switching, but the paper test says they are stretched.
So the current lender holds a borrower who may be paying above the market rate and cannot leave.
The partial fix banks already tried
In 2023, Westpac, NAB and ANZ began applying a 1 or 2 per cent margin to certain applicants instead of the full 3 per cent. That helped some borrowers, but it is not a cure. With rates at their highest since 2008, a 7.73 per cent test on a 6.73 per cent loan is still a hard hurdle for many households.
It also shows the buffer has some flexibility in practice. The discretion exists. It is simply applied to some applicants and not others.
Equity is closing the second door
A second group is stuck for a different reason. Refinancers generally need 20 per cent equity to avoid lenders mortgage insurance. Falling capital-city prices are shrinking that cushion, so borrowers who once cleared the threshold can slip below it.
That adds a cost to leaving. Insurance can be worth paying if the saving on the new rate is large enough, but it changes the arithmetic and many borrowers will not run it.
For related reading on how valuation can derail a switch, see our piece on refinancing valuation traps in Melbourne.
Who benefits when borrowers cannot move
Incumbent lenders gain the most. A customer who cannot leave is a customer who does not need a sharper rate to stay. Retention pricing matters less when the exit door is partly locked by a rule rather than by competition.
That does not mean banks designed it. The buffer comes from the regulator, and the intent is prudential. But the effect is quieter competition for existing customers, and that sits awkwardly alongside the goal of keeping lenders honest on price.
Could a tweak ease it without adding risk?
This is the real policy question. The current approach treats a new loan and a refinance the same, even though a refinance of an existing loan with a clean repayment record carries different risk. The borrower is already servicing the debt.
One option is a lighter buffer for like-for-like refinances where the repayment would not rise. Another is a longer track record test, so a proven payer is not asked to prove ability to pay a rate nobody is offering. The trade-off is that any loosening reduces the cushion if rates keep rising, and regulators will want evidence it does not weaken lending standards. We do not know where they will land, only that the question is now being asked loudly.
What stuck borrowers can try
There are practical levers, and none require waiting for a policy change:
- Ask your current lender for a better rate. Many will move once they know you are shopping around.
- Raise your borrowing capacity by cutting credit card limits, paying down other debts and trimming discretionary spending before you apply.
- Run the maths on lenders mortgage insurance. If the rate saving outweighs the premium, paying it can still be rational.
The pressure behind all of this is the same: the rate you are tested at is not the rate you will pay. Until that gap narrows, either through policy or lower rates, some borrowers will stay put by rule rather than by choice.
If you are thinking about switching, start with our home loans and refinancing guide, then subscribe to the newsletter for the weekly signal.
General info, not financial advice.
