Australian lenders may be charging more on home loans than their own funding costs justify, and the gap has been sticking around. That is the core claim in new modelling from University of Melbourne researchers, and it lands just as the cash rate sits at 4.85 per cent and the big four prepare to pass on the latest move.
The headline number is striking. On the researchers’ modelling, a Victorian borrower with an average loan of $664,000 would be looking at a gap worth about $628 a month. That is a modelled figure, not a measured loss, and the author is explicit about that. But the mechanism behind it is worth understanding properly.
What the researchers actually modelled
The team compared what lenders charge on home loans with what financial-market funding costs would imply. The difference between the two is the gap. In plain English: if a bank’s cost of money falls or rises, how quickly does the price you pay follow?
Roughly 70 per cent of the gap is attributed to slow adjustment when funding costs shift. The remaining 30 per cent or so is put down to lending risk and other operating expenses. So the finding is less about one-off gouging and more about a habit of moving slowly, in a direction that tends to suit the lender.
Key numbers
- Average Victorian loan in the modelling: $664,000
- Modelled monthly gap: $628
- Cash rate: 4.85 per cent in early November
- Share of gap tied to slow adjustment: about 70 per cent
Why a slow pass-through can persist
The lead academic suggests weak competition may play a part. That is a hypothesis, not a proven finding, but the logic is simple. If borrowers rarely move, a lender has little reason to chase them with a sharper rate. Loyalty becomes a cost that falls on the customer who stays put.
Brokers describe the same pattern from the ground. Loyal customers tend to lose out, and some borrowers cannot switch even when they would like to, because their serviceability, equity or circumstances no longer clear another lender’s test. That second group matters. A pricing gap only disciplines a lender when the borrower can credibly walk.
The catch is that this is where non-bank and smaller lenders can look attractive. They compete on price precisely because they do not have a large base of sticky customers to fall back on. Whether that advantage holds through a hiking cycle depends on their own funding costs, which is outside what this research tests.
What it does to borrowing capacity
The researchers also translate the gap into affordability. For a household on $104,390, borrowing capacity falls from about $540,000 to $462,000 under the modelling. Affordability is estimated to fall 14.3 per cent on one method and 11.1 per cent on another.
That range is the honest way to read it. Different methods give different answers, and neither is a forecast of what any one buyer will actually be offered. Still, the direction is clear. A pricing premium does not just raise repayments. It shrinks the size of the loan a buyer can be approved for, which feeds straight into what they can bid.
Refinancing and the rate-hike timing
With big four pass-through due on 13 November, the timing is awkward for anyone sitting on a variable loan. Each hike resets the question of whether your current rate still compares well with the market.
If you hold a variable loan, the practical test is simple:
- Check your current rate against what lenders are advertising to new customers.
- Ask your lender directly whether a retention rate is available.
- Compare the saving against any switching costs and your current equity position.
- If you cannot switch, negotiate anyway. Lenders do sometimes move when asked.
None of this proves the modelling is right. But a gap between what you pay and what a competitor offers is observable today, whatever the academic argument.
What this research cannot tell us
The author stresses these are modelled outcomes. They are not actual losses to borrowers, and they are not proof of excess bank profit. Funding costs differ between lenders, risk is priced differently, and banks have real expenses that the model only partly captures.
What the work does offer is a case for a transparent benchmark. If borrowers could see a clear reference point for what funding costs imply, they would have a firmer basis to question their lender. That idea may turn out to be more useful than the dollar figures themselves.
Start here: pull up your current rate this week and compare it with the best new-customer offer you can find. If the difference is meaningful, make the call. For more on where the major lenders stand right now, see our look at major bank profits and the jump in impairment charges, and for the borrower side of the cycle, how RBA rate hikes are hitting mortgage holders.
Want the weekly signal in your inbox? Subscribe to the newsletter.
General info, not financial advice.
