Australia’s Big Four banks are pricing in another rate hike before year-end, but brokers working the loan pipeline daily say interest rates aren’t the only force, or even the dominant one, shaping who’s buying and who’s waiting. The story emerging from inquiry volumes and settlement patterns is more segmented: upgraders are back, first-home buyers are still competing hard, and investors have largely stepped aside.
That split matters because it signals where resilience sits in the market and which segments will absorb the next rate move without flinching.
Who’s actually transacting right now
Brokers in Brisbane and Melbourne report a sharp uptick in upgraders over the past fortnight. The driver isn’t aspiration, it’s arithmetic. Renovation quotes have climbed to the point where buying a finished property in a softer market pencils out better than adding a second storey or reconfiguring a layout.
At the same time, first-home buyer inquiry remains elevated. The dynamic flips the usual script: instead of being priced out, they’re finding less competition at open homes and fewer multi-offer scenarios. Prices in some pockets have eased back to January or February levels, and for buyers who’ve been watching from the sidelines for months, that registers as opportunity.
Investor activity, by contrast, has cooled noticeably since the federal budget. Policy uncertainty around tax treatment and negative gearing changes has left many waiting to see how settings shake out before committing capital.
The renovation calculation that’s shifting demand
Upgraders aren’t moving because they’ve outgrown their homes, they’re moving because the cost of staying put and renovating has become prohibitive. Tradies are booked months out, materials are still expensive, and council approvals add time and risk.
Buying a property that already has the kitchen, the extra bedroom, or the outdoor space removes the project management burden and caps the total outlay. With more stock on the market than in late 2025, upgraders have choice without the pressure to overpay.
This segment tends to have equity, stable income, and higher serviceability buffers. They can absorb a 25-basis-point rate rise without restructuring their finances. That makes them less rate-sensitive than leveraged investors or stretched first-timers.
First-home buyers: still hot, just less frantic
First-home buyer inquiry hasn’t dropped, it’s shifted in character. Twelve months ago, the fear was missing out. Now, the focus is getting value. Buyers are taking longer to decide, negotiating harder, and walking away from properties that don’t meet their checklist.
But they’re still transacting. Reduced competition from investors and fewer cashed-up upgraders in the mix means fewer bidders at auction and more private-treaty sales where first-timers can negotiate without a crowd.
The risk for this cohort is serviceability. Another rate hike shrinks borrowing capacity by roughly 2–3% per 25-basis-point increase, depending on the lender’s buffer. For buyers already at the edge of what they can borrow, that could mean stepping down a suburb or waiting another quarter.
Investor appetite and the budget overhang
Investor inquiry has dropped measurably since May. The federal budget didn’t introduce immediate tax changes, but the signal was enough to spook decision-making. Investors who were weighing up a second or third property are now waiting to see whether negative gearing gets wound back or capital gains tax treatment shifts.
This segment is the most rate-sensitive by design. Investors rely on leverage to make returns work, and higher rates compress yields while increasing holding costs. Even a small move in the cash rate can flip a marginally positive cashflow property into negative territory.
If policy settings stabilise and the RBA pauses or cuts in 2027, investor demand could return quickly. But for now, this cohort is sidelined.
The catch
- Upgrader demand is contingent on renovation costs staying high, if tradie availability improves or materials costs fall, that driver weakens
- First-home buyers have serviceability buffers that shrink fast with each rate rise, one more hike could cut borrowing capacity enough to remove this segment from the market
- Investor appetite depends on policy clarity, not just rates, if negative gearing remains untouched but lending standards tighten further, the outcome is the same
What brokers are watching next
Broker inquiry volumes tend to lead transaction settlement by 60–90 days. If upgrader and first-home buyer inquiry holds through June, that translates to settled sales in August and September, enough to keep auction clearance rates and price indices stable even if investor activity stays muted.
But if the RBA does hike in September, as one of the Big Four is forecasting, serviceability will tighten and borrowing capacity will contract. That hits first-timers hardest, because they’re already borrowing at the top of their range.
Upgraders with equity and lower loan-to-value ratios can absorb the rate move. Investors, already on pause, won’t re-enter until either rates fall or policy certainty returns.
The other variable is listing volume. If more stock comes to market over winter, either from upgraders selling or investors offloading properties they can’t hold, prices soften further and buyer appetite strengthens. If listings stay tight, the upgrader and first-timer surge could stabilise prices faster than the headline rate story suggests.
For more on how real wages and house prices are moving in opposite directions and why that matters for demand, see Real wages falling as house prices drop: why nobody’s winning. And if you’re tracking how wealth effects influence consumer spending and recession risk, this breakdown explains the 10% house price threshold.
If you’re deciding whether to upgrade, invest, or wait, start by pressure-testing your serviceability against a 50-basis-point buffer above today’s rates. If your cashflow or borrowing capacity breaks at that level, you’re already at risk.
Subscribe to the newsletter for the weekly market signal delivered to your inbox each Monday.
General info, not financial advice.
