Capital city home values are cheaper, but fewer buyers can use it

A cheaper house is only a bargain if a bank will lend you the money to buy it. That is the problem sitting under the latest national numbers. Cotality’s November housing data shows capital city home values down 8.1% in seven months, but the same data shows a typical household’s borrowing capacity has fallen by roughly $88,000 over the same stretch. For many buyers, the price cut has been more than cancelled out.

Cheaper homes, smaller loans

Here is the arithmetic that matters. A household on the median income can now borrow about $88,000 less than it could at the start of the year. A price fall of 8.1% on a typical capital city home is a large dollar saving, but it does not automatically restore what the lender will approve. Five rate rises have lifted the cost of every borrowed dollar, and the serviceability buffer lenders apply on top makes the effect bigger than the headline rate suggests.

Repayments tell the same story from the other side. On a loan of about $742,000, the monthly cost is up around $600, or 14%, since January. That is a real squeeze on existing owners. For a prospective buyer, it means the maximum loan they qualify for has shrunk at the same moment sellers have become more willing to negotiate.

Key numbers

  • Capital city values: down 8.1% in seven months
  • Median-income borrowing capacity: down about $88,000
  • Repayments on a $742,000 loan: up about $600 a month (14%)
  • Days to sell: 41, up from 24
  • Vendor discounts: 4.5%
  • Weekly clearance rate on 1 November: 40.7%

Buyers hold leverage, but not much cash flow

The market has clearly tilted. Homes are taking 41 days to sell instead of 24, vendors are giving up 4.5% off their asking prices, and the weekly clearance rate sank to 40.7% on 1 November. A buyer who is approved and ready has bargaining power they did not have a year ago.

The catch is that approval is the bottleneck. Falling prices usually bring more buyers back into a market. This time the same rate settings that pushed prices down are also cutting the size of the loan each buyer can get. That is why a sharp price fall and a thin buyer pool can exist side by side. The people best placed to use the discount are those with a large deposit or existing equity, not the household stretching to get in.

A fixed rate that costs more than variable

There is also a pricing quirk worth noticing. Fixed rates for terms of up to three years sit at 6.36%, above the average variable rate of 6.22%. Normally, fixing buys certainty at a small premium or a discount. Here, lenders are charging more for locking in, which suggests they expect rates to stay high for a while rather than ease quickly.

That expectation lines up with the view that cuts look unlikely before late 2027. Borrowers waiting for relief should plan around a long stretch at current settings, not a quick reversal.

The decline is uneven by city

Not every capital is behaving the same way. Sydney is furthest from its peak, with values 10.1% below February’s high. Perth is down 8.9% and Brisbane 8.3%. Mid-sized capitals have taken the heaviest hits, because strong post-COVID gains had already pushed affordability to its limit there before the rate rises started.

Supply adds another layer. Melbourne’s market is described as tight, while Adelaide and Brisbane carry roughly 25% oversupply. In an oversupplied market, falling demand tends to show up more directly in prices and discounting. In a tighter one, sellers can hold out longer.

What the record comparison does and does not tell us

The current slide sits just under the previous worst peak-to-trough fall of 8.2%, recorded between 2017 and 2019, and a Cotality research head expects the new downturn to overtake it next month. That is a striking marker, but it does not say how far this one will go. The earlier fall was driven largely by tighter credit and investor lending rules. This one is driven by interest rates and borrowing capacity, which can behave differently if rates stop rising.

The honest read is that nobody can name the bottom. What can be said is that the speed of the drop suggests the market was priced for lower rates than it got.

A practical read for different readers

If you are a buyer with strong serviceability, the current conditions offer more negotiating room than you have had in years. Get your borrowing capacity checked with more than one lender before you bid, because assessment methods differ.

If you are an existing borrower, the higher fixed rates mean refinancing is worth checking, but compare the full cost of switching. Our home loans, lenders and refinancing guide is a good starting point. Those with thin equity should also read our look at who holds the thinnest buffers as values fall.

If you are an investor, a weaker market and stretched borrowing power are not the same as an opportunity. Cashflow buffers matter more than the discount.

Want the weekly signal on rates and prices? Subscribe to the Australian Property Review newsletter.

General info, not financial advice.

Share this article

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here